Can't seem to get enough of this cd. The mandolin picking by both is sublime - particularly on the tunes Muddy Creek and Little Bessie. Anyone else feel the same or have worked out these versions?
Can't seem to get enough of this cd. The mandolin picking by both is sublime - particularly on the tunes Muddy Creek and Little Bessie. Anyone else feel the same or have worked out these versions?
Here's a version I transcribed. It doesn't include the mandola part
-Phil
Muddy Creek is one of the neatest tunes I've heard in the last year or so. #I am still looking for anyone in my neck of the woods (middle TN) who has even heard of it, let alone plays it. #There is a version tabbed out (by Mike Buesseler) it the TAB section. #His melody is close to what I hear. #Phil, in the first half of the A part (meaures 4-6) the melody is a bit different and doesn't go up to the high "B", like it does in the 2nd phrase.
Because there is no guitar accompaniment, it's tricky to hear all the chords suggested by the two instruments, but I hear some additional chords. #For example, if you listen to the mandola harmony, the progression: D/D/D/D/G/D/Bm/A #seems to be suggested in the A part.
There's also a neat variation in the B part accompaniment/harmony on alternate times through the tune, with the mandola/harmony suggesting more of a G/G/D/D/Em/D/GD/AD.
Wish we could sit down and all play it.
Jeff Rohrbough
"Listen louder, play softer"
one of my all time favorites - Majroies Waltz # 3 - nice to hear Nancy back on the Cello - and Mr. Pete doin mandola!
I picked that up at a Peter Ostroushko show a few years back - he played here in Jan and I missed it - kicking my self.
The version of #Muddy Creek that I transcribed in the TAB section is as close to the recorded melody as I could get it (pretty close, I think). #
My partner and I don't play mandola, so the second part is written for mandolin. #I made it up, trying to capture the feeling of Peter O's mandola part. #My buddy reworked it some to his liking and we got us a great duet! #I play melody, five times through, my partner plays 5 different variations along with it. #We consider it one of our best pieces.
I forgot in my previous post - another favorite from this CD is the tune "Oklahoma Redwing", played by Peter O. For a tune entirely in C/G, that one is pretty interesting. It is virtually imossible to tab out any one melody for that, as he plays probably 10 variations. Another one that no one I have ever asked has heard of.
Jeff Rohrbough
"Listen louder, play softer"
marjorie's waltz #3 is my favorite on that album. i also like peter's down from the red lodge album. teelin bay waltz is my fave on that one.
"your posts ... very VERY opinionated ...basing your opinion/recommendations ... pot calling ...kettle... black...sarcasm...comment ...unwarranted...unnecessary...."
Acousticphd--
I think you meant "Oklahoma Redbird." #I found this...don't know if it's the same tune.
Oklahoma Redbird
You are correct, thanks. And that transcription is the same melody, but in Bb (ugh!), not C. .Originally Posted by
Jeff Rohrbough
"Listen louder, play softer"
I use a program called Melody Assistant. I punched in the notes as shown on that sheet, then just did a "fast transpose" to C. Neat little tune. Wish I could play it for you...
Don't know why I didn't think of this before. #Melody Asst also exports to a variety of file types, including ABC. #Lots of other programs read ABC, so here is Oklahoma Redbird, Key of C.
M:2/4 # #
L:1/16 # #
K:C
z4 z2 EF |:G2^FG AG=FG |EGcd e2de |fedc BGBd |cedc BAGE |G2^FG AG=FG |EGcd e2de |fedc BGBd |[1cedB c2EF :|[2cedB c2GB |c2Gc e2ce |g2eg c'2ga |b2gb a^fdf |a2ga gfed |c2Gc e2ce |g2eg c'2ga |b2ab afdB |c2dB c2GB ||
c2Gc e2ce |g2eg c'2ga |b2gb a^fdf |a2ga gfed |c2Gc e2ce |g2eg c'2ga |b2ab afdB |c2dB c4 |]
This is my current favorite CD! Thanks for the files.
I really like the "Log Hut Down the Lane" song -- am planning to learn that with my band to play.
Anyone ever heard that version of Blackberry Blossom before?
Cheers,
Rob
Follow the Flatt Stanley Incident on Facebook
Listen to original tune "When You Fly" by my old band The Kindreds
Yes, sort of - there is version on the CD "All I've Got's Done Gone" (Rhys Jones, fiddle, I don't remember the the others) with similar melody, but at a lickety split pace.
Jeff Rohrbough
"Listen louder, play softer"
That would include Jeff Miller on Banjo and Jim Nelson on guitar. They have a second CD out now entitled Mississippi Square Dance. Both CDs are on the Vigortone Records label. Highly recommended stuff!
-Phil
Much obliged to all for the input. Nice job Mike w/ the tab - you saved me hours of time learning the tune!
I love those ringing open strings - especially playing solo.
The "Oklahoma Redbird" version written in Bb is actually not that difficult, especially compared to "President Garfield's Hornpipe" which is usually shown in Bb and can be an utter beast. I think it's worthwhile to dabble in Bb major since the fingering gets you to G minor, lending some facility for example on Monroe's "Kentucky Mandolin" which I've always thought was one of the prettiest tunes on the planet. Yesyesyes of course it's desirable to be able to play in any key, but some of them clearly show greater promise than others, depending on your context and priorities. -- Paul
He joyously felt himself idling, an unreflective mood in which water was water, sky was sky, breeze was breeze. He knew it couldn't last. -- Thomas McGuane, "Nothing but Blue Skies"
Hey, do any of you have the new Ostroushko recording "Minnesota, a history of the land"? #I posted a little review here a few weeks back.
Last weekend I sat down and learned 2 tunes from it. #A slow, brooding tune "Metis" (D minor) with nice droned strings, and the upbeat "Plowman's Reel" (G). #
The nice thing is that the tunes are slow enough that I could actually pick them out off of the CD without tracking back to hear every individual note.
The record is not mandolin-heavy, but there is some cool "epic" sounding stuff on there.
Z
Member since 2003!
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks