OK, I have $5000 to spend. Let me have an opinion as to the best mandolin for around that price.
OK, I have $5000 to spend. Let me have an opinion as to the best mandolin for around that price.
A, F or 2 point? Type of music you play mostly? Knowing that will help but a lot will come down to personal preference for sound, neck shape and feel. You should be able to find a great mandolin for your budget.
I play bluegrass and oldtime. Prefer a F style. Currently looking at Collings and Weber
For five grand I'd buy the best used F style I could find. You can find luthier built instruments in that range. You would get the low end of new F styles for that. The exception that comes to mind is the Northfield Big Mon, a worthy contender in any company.
But just look at what you can get in the classifieds. Not saying a Collings MF wouldn't do you very nicely.
Silverangel A
Arches F style kit
1913 Gibson A-1
It’s the one you played that sounded the best, to you. Gibson, Flatiron, Weber, Collings and Ratliff come to mind. You can spend all or part of your budget there.
I don’t think there’s a ‘best’, but there will be a voice that really speaks to you. Listen well.
Not all the clams are at the beach
Arrow Manouche
Arrow Jazzbo
Arrow G
Clark 2 point
Gibson F5L
Gibson A-4
Ratliff CountryBoy A
Nice budget. Visit a store that has as many to play as possible. Know that mandolins sound different in a large room. Wander off somewhere cozy to play. You will likely chose one that you never considered.
Check out a Girouard , built by Max Girouard !
It all depends on what kind of sound you're going for.
In addition to all the mandolins previously mentioned, 5K will get you a nice F-4.
Or you might drive over to Gruhn's and take a look at the Wienman.
As a matter of fact, I count 40 mandolins between $4000 and $5500 in Nashville: 11 at Gruhn's, and 29 at Carter's. You're within easy driving distance. Spend an afternoon there, and hopefully you'll find something that suits you.
Last edited by rcc56; Apr-06-2019 at 9:16pm.
For wooden musical fun that doesn't involve strumming, check out:
www.busmanwhistles.com
Handcrafted pennywhistles in exotic hardwoods.
Take a few days to visit Nashville. Bring your current mandolin and play it side by side with every mandolin in your price range at Gruhn's and Carter's. Ask to use a private room where you can really listen without distraction. I would play the ones that you like a few times over a day or 2.
I would pay particular attention to this one:
https://cartervintage.com/collection...iwamoto-f5-new
If it is as good as the one at Dusty Strings, you'll be hard pressed to find better at that price:
Also, If you have cash in hand, I'm sure you can negotiate the price by 5-10%.
Collings MF Deluxe
(Or if you can find a used Gibson f5 Custom from TMS with the big frets...)
I'm obviously biased
*2002 Collings MT2
*2016 Gibson F5 Custom
*Martin D18
*Deering Sierra
I would buy the Elkhorn currently listed in the classifieds here on MC.
Last edited by Bob Buckingham; Apr-07-2019 at 4:23pm. Reason: link was wrong
Avenue Guitars has a sweet used Weber Fern at $4,500....
https://www.avenueguitars.com/collec...-mandolin-2004
But...for the same price they have an incredible new Northfield Big Mon...the only black top that I ever thought I'd want to own!
https://www.avenueguitars.com/collec...top-sn-b190134
Last edited by Al Trujillo; Apr-07-2019 at 8:55pm. Reason: Added Northfield information
Spend the day in Nashville. Play everything. Pick the one you like best.
Collings and Weber are making some awesome instruments right now, so I don’t think you could go wrong with either, but I agree, make the trip over to Nashville and play as many as you can. You may find a Collings or Weber that you love, or you might be surprised what speaks to you, and by what you think you’d love but don’t...
Chuck
I just played a collection of 7 Webers at a local store. Two clearly had it [if you're talking projection, woody/deep tones, and sweetness far up the neck] ... which were the most expensive one, and one of two seemingly identical Gallatins. Playing those two Gallatins back and forth was weird as despite the same looks there seemed to be such a strong difference between the two, one just sang. Everything else were fine mandolins, but it was a good personal reminder that buying in person is worth a pretty large amount of effort.
I'm upgrading in a month or so and was planning on ordering online - now realize that I'd rather delay it a few weeks and even drop the budget by a few hundred bucks to afford playing them all in person.
With my last instrument there was one on the wall that seemed superior, I am hoping this time it's the same experience.
I am generally not a fan of Webers and am not looking for an F style - but I nearly walked away with that one Gallatin as it was among the nicest $3k F styles I've played in a long long time.
Collings MT2
Breedlove OF
Ellie eMando
Schmergl Devastator
An open mind and a town like Nashville, coupled with a healthy budget equals a great buying experience.
Silverangel A
Arches F style kit
1913 Gibson A-1
This Weber Big Sky has been posted on Classified's...very nice! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYT5195S67E
Unforeseen circumstance had me going to Gryphon just two weeks after my last visit, and I paid extra attention to the Collings line of f styles. What Collings does really well, IMHO, is nail the fine line between resonance and bright cutting tone. My Arches kit is quite a bit louder, has a pleasant tone, but doesn't have the richness Collings builds into their mandolins. Never mind the fit and finish Collings provides.
But the price is steep. Well so is every other f style. I doubt my shaiiowness could live with the basic MF, but the MF Deluxe is a beauty. Much above that and the sphincter factor takes over. I am also enamored with the Merlot finish. Sight unseen, a Collings is as safe a bet as you can get. But even then, the ones I played yesterday were not created equal. All were very good.
Silverangel A
Arches F style kit
1913 Gibson A-1
Bookmarks