Re: Morgan Monroe Question
TL;DR: I'm pretty sure MM mandolins are made mostly in larger facilities mostly by machine.
My first F style was a Morgan Monroe Tree of Life inlaid fingerboard I also got from Folk of the Wood. It looked really good and was a nice beginner mandolin. It intonated well and the tuners held. The finish was thick. IIRC, mine was made in Korea (2003 is when I bought it new) and it likely didn't have much hand work done on the plates. Morgan Monroe certainly wasn't using hand carved as part of their marketing at the time. It sure sounded like a mandolin to me but wasn't particularly loud or notable for it's voice. I feel my Eastman mandolins 2005 and 2008 for an F oval and two point with f holes respectively sounded much better with the handwork and thinner finish. In general I think unless they are explicit with the specs expect the least amount of handwork on an instrument. If it doesn't say solid wood, assume plywood (which can be fine), if it doesn't say carved, assume pressed to shape, if it doesn't say hand carved, assume all CNC, if it says handcarved assume likely rough work by machine or CNC and then the close up work done by hand.
I'm not an advanced player nor do I gig. I haven't played with others in a long time. My requirements for a pricey (above $2K) instrument isn't there anymore. If it sounds good and feels good, it is good. If it sounds good from across the room to you it is good. But, I wouldn't assume all the models and individuals across the line to be equal from most of the overseas ones. That's why you have a conversation, play before buying, or have a decent return arrangement (even if you're on the hook for shipping both ways that's fair for the convenience of online shopping-IMO).
I'm very much with Allen on this re: how they are made and consistency across lines and brands but, I'll add it's been a long time since I was new mandolin shopping. I wouldn't blindly trade my Eastman for a Morgan Monroe. Maybe if I played them side by side and the MM sounded at least as good and in my experience, that would be a surprise. Even though my playing proficiency has not really improved too much, I'm picky enough about how they feel in hand anymore that I would want to at least have some examples in hand before I bought a production mandolin to be sure I liked the fit.
Jamie
There are two things to aim at in life: first, to get what you want; and, after that, to enjoy it. Only the wisest of mankind achieve the second. Logan Pearsall Smith, 1865 - 1946
+ Give Blood, Save a Life +
Bookmarks