I'd say if its a keeper leave her be! I think it looks great! I'm no pinky planter but have to have a pickguard as a guide of sorts-yeah its a mental thing! "I know I've got a complex!" But to me looks aren't that important, it should be all about the tone, sound overall voice etc...But there are some people I've learned that just can't handle a scratch, ding or even a hairline but hey when some instruments are 100+years they will have battle scars!
Bookmarks