No.Do we need labels at all?
A music label does not provide much more information than knowing the name of a stranger to whom you are being introduced. There is some utility in knowing the name of the stranger, but it doesn't tell you much about him.
Bobby Bill
The answer is simple: If Bill would have liked it, then it's Bluegrass. Everything else is no part of nothin'!
Living in the Mitten
Big Muddy M-2W
Rover RM-50 A-style
Epiphone AJ-200 A/E
Electrics & amps gathering dust
Mississippi Harmonica
Two dimes to rub together
Start anywhere.
I'm going to have to disagree. We do need labels, because there are more musicians working than one person can possibly be familiar with. Are they too restrictive, or misapplied? Sure, sometimes. But I need some sorting tool to help find music I like. What I think is a mistake is to take a label and apply it as a rule. It's just shorthand. Music isn't a binary solution.
A "bluegrass taser" in hot pink oy veh? (in my grandmother's heavy Yiddish accent)
Bluegrass (to me) can be compared to the Golden Delicious apple. It's genus can be brought back to one singular tree. (in Iowa BTW) Bluegrass, by it's purist definition is music created by Bill Monroe and his Bluegrass Boys. Period, end of an ending.
Stanley Bros. even claimed similar as "mountain (style) music." as to seperate themselves. What brings me to my point:
While we sit around the festival fires and spit into the embers, and argue/diss_cuss about who played it first, yada yada. The actual professional pickers and players of said music actually try to seperate themself's from the crowd. You can't make real money sounding exactly like somebody else. Not only that, it's dang tuff to even corner them into a discussion about this kind of stuff. It doesn't do them pros any good making one friend over here, and creating a hundred enemies over there. I really try to follow their example, by picking/playing three to four times more than i visit, around the campfire.
Jussayin'
Lithium! I'm due for an upgrade!!
Can that taser pierce through the bellows of an accordian, that's all i wanna know?
Integrated LED light - illuminate dark environments
Now THAT is a handy feature...I wonder if this comes also with a hallucinogenic option?
I think it needs a metronome that cannot be set below 300 BPM.
All the Best
Michael
But that's old-time music. That's where bluegrass came from, but that's not what it is, or ever was.
In bluegrass, a mandolin or a guitar can be just as loud as a banjo or a fiddle -- or even louder. To accomplish that, a band needs to have at least one microphone and understand how to use it. Bluegrass is a technology-dependent form of music developed in concert stages and recording studios. It was created not on front porches in the hills, but in the big cities by farm boys who had moved there in search of work. The '46 Blue Grass Boys sang about wanting to go back to the old place, but in order to develop the right kind of nostalgia they had to leave the old place first.
Emando.com: More than you wanted to know about electric mandolins.
Notorious: My Celtic CD--listen & buy!
Lyon & Healy Wood Thormahlen Andersen Bacorn Yanuziello Fender National Gibson Franke Fuchs Aceto Three Hungry Pit Bulls
If that Taser has an "auto," we have a definition.
If not, we'll just end up producing a lot of convuslive drooling around the campfire. And that would rob banjo players of their niche.
I saw Homer & Jethro once. This mandolin therapy isn't helping me get over it.
'04 Andersen A (for keeps)
Amateur Gibson F copy (for travel)
Santa Rosa student model A (for the neighbor kids)
If you put what I said in context, I was making the point that the people who played "classic bluegrass," and whom the bluegrass "purists" hold up as exemplifying the One True Sound, were a bit more eclectic than perhaps their disciples mention. They strayed from "strict construction" at times, experimenting with different sounds, sometimes at the behest of record companies looking for greater commercial success. Monroe's recording a few Jimmie Rodgers numbers with an electric guitarist, doesn't mean that he abandoned his basic band structure and musical sound. But over his recording career, he included instruments from vibraphone (Christmas Time's A-Coming), to organ on some gospel numbers, to near-orchestral backup on some Master of Bluegrass cuts. He recorded duets with Barbara Mandrell, Waylon Jennings, the Gatlin Brothers et. al., also.
I don't have a definition for "bluegrass," much less "non-standard bluegrass," though I'd say the latter is probably any departure from the IBGMA-approved lineup and instrumentation, or the presentation of largely non-"country" material. Just attended a show by the excellent band Nothin' Fancy yesterday, and they were, I guess, pretty "classic bluegrass" in instrumentation, singing and instrumental styles, yet in their show they did songs from Creedence Clearwater, Bob Seger, Bruce Springsteen, Bill Withers, Tom T. Hall, and a variety of other "non-bluegrass" sources. I guess, from the band's history, that they have the Bluegrass Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval, yet they performed material and put on a stage show that wouldn't have suited the Blue Grass Boys very well.
Maybe we ought to recognize that "bluegrass" is becoming a broader label, like "country," "jazz," or "blues," and adopt the "classic bluegrass" sub-genre designation for the most "trad" part of that spectrum. I don't think that Grady Martin or Wilene "Sally Ann" Forrester -- or DeFord Bailey, also once part of Monroe's show -- "proves" that "anything goes, and you can still call it 'bluegrass.'" I do think that departures from the "classic form" like this indicate that major bluegrass artists can test the limits of the genre -- or, rather, not recognize that it has such narrow limits.
Allen Hopkins
Gibsn: '54 F5 3pt F2 A-N Custm K1 m'cello
Natl Triolian Dobro mando
Victoria b-back Merrill alumnm b-back
H-O mandolinetto
Stradolin Vega banjolin
Sobell'dola Washburn b-back'dola
Eastmn: 615'dola 805 m'cello
Flatiron 3K OM
I would rather play "classic bluegrass" than eat, but have to admit i love Sam Bush and David Grisman. So what does that make me?
Emando.com: More than you wanted to know about electric mandolins.
Notorious: My Celtic CD--listen & buy!
Lyon & Healy Wood Thormahlen Andersen Bacorn Yanuziello Fender National Gibson Franke Fuchs Aceto Three Hungry Pit Bulls
Just like jazz, to faithfully pay homage to the original, you must know where it comes from, to know where you're going. It's all good.
The flipside being the little dude in the xtrnormal cartoon:
"i've got deep tradeeshawnal roots teuw. I go back to the first Neeckel Creek Album."
i'll bet IBMA officially lists a dobro.
Slippery slope.
Dogs & Cats living together.
TOTAL MAYHEM! ! ! ! !
This story may be relevant. A few years ago, I was chatting with Frank Wakefield and Bobby Osborne at the mandocamp when Frank mentioned that he thought that Merle Travis derived his style from Mississippi John Hurt. I thought this was interesting and asked if they listened to much of this sort of music. Bobby responded that they were always listening to all sorts of music, looking for something that they could add to their own music to make it a little different so it would stand out from the rest. It looks to me like change or evolution in the music has been going on since the beginning and is indeed inherent in the music. Music is just the ocean and a particular style is just a wave (to paraphrase Jimmy Dale Gilmore). That being said, I don't think that it is a crime or even narrow minded to prefer to ride one particular wave.
Seriously, the general concept of classical bluegrass works for me / seems logical as in baroque, classical and romantic styles of "classical music." Huge differences too between Bach, Bach's son P.D.Q., Handel, Vivaldi and Telemann within each era. They refer to general periods of development over time - eras. Pretty sure Beethoven didn't care whether he was old Classical or new Romantic when he used an altered concept of the Baroque fugue. Also pretty sure there were endless discussions over all that too. In the end, it may be more important to describe the music than the style.
Less seriously, David Grisman ain't no part of Sam Bush. (Not that I won't be thrilled to see each of them.)
I saw Homer & Jethro once. This mandolin therapy isn't helping me get over it.
'04 Andersen A (for keeps)
Amateur Gibson F copy (for travel)
Santa Rosa student model A (for the neighbor kids)
Emando.com: More than you wanted to know about electric mandolins.
Notorious: My Celtic CD--listen & buy!
Lyon & Healy Wood Thormahlen Andersen Bacorn Yanuziello Fender National Gibson Franke Fuchs Aceto Three Hungry Pit Bulls
Bookmarks