I am in the market for a second mando. I play old time, Celtic, contra dance music; no bluegrass. My primary instrument is a Lafferty (Schneider) oval hole with modern neck. It suits me perfectly. I am interested in a comparable quality A model mandolin with f holes. I am interested in a Montana made Flatiron Performer A for $1000 (which I have not seen) and a 1939 Gibson A50 which I have examined. The Gibson is in nice shape except for exceedingly low action, a neck in need of TR adjustment, new strings, general set up. As a retired guitar tech, I can handle repairs and set up myself. As is, the Gibson sounds plinky and weak, like an old Harmony or Kay. The A50 is priced at $1100.
I am reasonably certain that the Flatiron will fit my needs, having owned two Flatiron A models years ago, which I was satisfied with.
But the Gibson intrigues me. What is the skinny on old A50s? Are they capable of the quality of sound that I am used to? Both mandolins are returnable, although the Gibson only offers 72 hours. The Gibson is at the GC in Knoxville.
Any input would be appreciated.
Bookmarks