Re: Next-generation Wood?
That's great! Should make your mandolin sound just like a banjo ;)
Re: Next-generation Wood?
That process is pretty much how some of the ebony substututes for fingerboards are made. You take some solid hardwood, dye, heat and compress it and you get stronger harder wood that works similarly to ebony. The product is suspectible to moisture so some companies also impregnate with resins...
Re: Next-generation Wood?
Well.....might be something, who knows? I'm sure somebody will give it a chance. Worth a try, IMHO. Something new.
Carbon Fiber isn't really my thing, but many people love it, for example.
A new Chevy is mostly plastic, but I would rather drive it to California than take a horse and buggy........
Airplanes were a new idea less than 120 years ago....
OTOH, there may be a "spiritual" reason that we want tonewoods to be naturally derived. Similar to how some people fear GMO foods.....
Kind of like being a vegetarian because I like my dog, even if she isn't a vegetarian.......
"We" can overthink these issues. A dog doesn't have that luxury....
Re: Next-generation Wood?
I can think of only a few reasons to use this wood for instruments. 1. Because it is cheaper, and/or 2. Because it is more durable, i.e., less susceptible to environmental effects. Both of those reasons are good enough to try it.
It seems very unlikely that a mandolin, at least, made from this product would ever rival good traditional mandolins in the market place. Nothing else ever has. Which is not to say no one should or will try it. Cheap and durable has its place.
Re: Next-generation Wood?
I once played an electric guitar manufactured completely from machined aluminum billet. It sounded awful to me. But I'm sure that someone with skills could employ it to make a noise that was of some value to someone. Tone happens.
Re: Next-generation Wood?
Wrcnbndr—Makes you wonder WHY?
Re: Next-generation Wood?
As a guy who has really really tried to understand the electric guitar for twenty years and tried to squeeze every bit of understanding out of every encounter with a superior instrument, I'm resigned to calling some things mojo as they are beyond my comprehension. Yes, there are things that generally work better than other things and there are recipes in construction that consistently yield a certain character. But tone will happen one way or another. It then just becomes a matter of whether or not that tone will be appreciated.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9-ltPsbw9g
Re: Next-generation Wood?
If you want it to sound like wood, why not, IDK, use wood? Perhaps we could expend human efforts to plant trees on deforested areas. Vast amounts of corn and soy fields used to be hardwood trees.
Re: Next-generation Wood?
Now there’s a heck of an idea! ;)
Re: Next-generation Wood?
I went back to watch that video, Wrnch. Again, I wonder why? Because we can, I guess, is a good enough answer. But that shovel-guitar will not become a big seller...
Re: Next-generation Wood?
The day I first saw that video I went to my hardware store on purchased a double headed axe and basically did the same thing he did. It had better sustain -- not really. It sounded like an axe with strings. Tone happens.
Planting trees is fun and is good karma.
Re: Next-generation Wood?
Interesting connection between a new material and an application. I’m pretty sure that if we had to, for some reason, abandon current materials for instruments, we’d probably learn a lot about what made them ‘good’ and engineer similar or even better ones. After all, someone had to make the instrumental move to high-strength steel strings back when they were entirely new tech.
However, there seems to be great comfort in wood: furniture, buildings, instruments. And craftsmanship. And friendly mysteries.