Introduction of a new member
Hi All! My first post. I joined the forum because my daughter and I are about to embark on acquiring instruments and learning mandolin.
I'm a guitar player from way back. But life got in the way, so lots of years were lost in the interim. I'm a middle-aged now and still hammering around at it. I'm really excited to learn mandolin, and WAY More excited that my 16 y/o daughter is eager to start as well, and thus, this can be something that will help keep us close as she finishes the next few years of high school.
She plays piano, flute and french horn now (all in varying degrees of competency). But flute very well, and piano pretty good. And french horn as a mid-beginner.
I know we want to get F type. And I know me well enough to know that I may as well go big now, because I'll get there sooner or later anyway, and lose money on every flip on the way there. I'll probably get her something more intermediate. For now, I'm having fun shopping online, learning, and dreaming for now.
Anyway, just thought I'd introduce myself. I'm in Western PA, so shout out if you're local. Take care all!
Re: Introduction of a new member
Hi, r0gue.
Welcome aboard to you and your daughter. I have a daughter who's played trad music with me since she was a little child. It's rewarding to share these musical experiences. I have no advice for you, but you'll find the Forum a great place for support and advice. Ask any questions you have, and you'll get answers. Occasionally, everyone agrees.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Welcome to you and your daughter to the crazy world of mandolin!
Re: Introduction of a new member
Welcome to the world of MAS!
Re: Introduction of a new member
Welcome to the wonderful world of the mandolin. I am assuming that you are just introducing yourself. I will also assume that you are not asking for advice on what to buy though I am sure that people will offer it anyway. Just let us know if you want any of our opinions and I am sure you will get them.
Re: Introduction of a new member
I certainly welcome any and all advice. I will preface that with my sharing of my preference for American (or Canadian) made instruments. "Local" if you will.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Welcome! Also swing by the newbies social group and make yourself at home. You’ve come to the right place.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Well done, sounds like a lot of fun!
I guess you know about the Suzuki method for joint lessons?
It’s a method for people who have differing levels of competence or resources (one area in one person compliments another often quite different area in someone else).
It’s to avoid judgements like: you can only be in our band if you’re as good as us, and it works well for people who have previous and long term, committed social attachments.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Simon DS
Well done, sounds like a lot of fun!
I guess you know about the Suzuki method for joint lessons?
I do not, but will research. And perhaps whatever teacher we find will as well. I'm thinking to some degree, her mastery of theory will be as helpful as my experience with strings.
Thanks!
Re: Introduction of a new member
Quote:
Originally Posted by
r0gue
I certainly welcome any and all advice. I will preface that with my sharing of my preference for American (or Canadian) made instruments. "Local" if you will.
ln that case it always helps to know a few other details. What are your budgets for these instruments? What genres do you want to play? No doubt that you will hear the statement that you get more bang for your buck with an A-style mandolin with sacrificing tone as for the F you will be paying for cosmetics of producing a more complicated design. Also you mention going big for your choice. I am not sure what that means. Also, have you played many mandolins and are you interested in contemporary mandolins or would you consider vintage ones?
Since you are in Western PA, have you been to Acoustic Music Works in Pittsburgh. It looks like they have an excellent selection of mandolins: https://acousticmusicworks.com/collections/mandolins
Re: Introduction of a new member
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Jim Garber
ln that case it always helps to know a few other details. What are your budgets for these instruments? What genres do you want to play? No doubt that you will hear the statement that you get more bang for your buck with an A-style mandolin with sacrificing tone as for the F you will be paying for cosmetics of producing a more complicated design. Also you mention going big for your choice. I am not sure what that means. Also, have you played many mandolins and are you interested in contemporary mandolins or would you consider vintage ones?
Since you are in Western PA, have you been to Acoustic Music Works in Pittsburgh. It looks like they have an excellent selection of mandolins:
https://acousticmusicworks.com/collections/mandolins
Well, for me personally, I definitely prefer the F type, but my daughter may end up with an A type if she likes them or if there's not a strong preference. Budget is very open-ended. I tend to be a buy once and keep it, rather than trade my way up. And I always end up getting tempted up, so the shortest path/straight line thing... Plus I look at it as money stored, not money spent. They retain value well if you buy quality well.
I am open to vintage, but when looking at some like on Carter Vintage Exchange, I'm really in awe of how expensive they can get. Like six digits expensive! :disbelief: But I am definitely planning to be in the four digits. And as I prefer an American crafted mandolin (or guitar for that matter), I'll be above the lowest of the four digits eh?
I have used AMW for some work on my guitar before. They have some gorgeous mandolins. Hoping to get back down there soon. Couple of good guys in that shop. I have not played many mandolins yet.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Re: Introduction of a new member
Welcome to the forum.
I’m with you about the F body. I have a serious case of scroll envy by myself. But an American made F body? That’s tough without writing a big check.
Check out the Acoustic Shoppe and their shop special Gibson F9s. American made, premium tonewood, wide nut, radius fretboard. Check out some of their YouTube videos of them playing the Gibson F9.
That price tag though…
Absolutely nothing wrong with a 500 or 600 series Eastman. I just recently bought an Eastman 514 for myself. One of those can easily be a lifetime instrument. Again check out some of the YouTube videos from the Acoustic Shoppe .
Re: Introduction of a new member
Also, go to The Mandolin Store and check out a Northfield Big Mon. A few dollars cheaper than a Gibson F9.
Both these stores are forum sponsors, and offer free shipping & free set up of online mandolin purchases.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Hi r0gue - I'm another newbie but welcome all the same! I'm in a similar place as you - guitar player who decided to pick up mandolin. One thing I've learned is that my guitar playing callouses weren't ready for the mandolin! The triumvirate of short-scale, high tension, and double strings is surprisingly tougher on my fingers than my guitars -although I adapted pretty quickly. Best of luck to you and your daughter in your mandolin journey.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Hi r0gue - Welcome... Glad you and your daughter will have some together time...I feel ya'. My fingers were pristine, no callouses. Long, long ago (35 yrs) in a galaxy far, far away, I attempted the Banjo as my first string instrument and got frustrated with the Scruggs Style picking - so I gave it up. Now retired, I have the time to pick up the mandolin (thought about it about 25 yrs ago). It's definitely a change from the Pipe Organ and Recorders, but I'm looking forward to the challenge.
Re: Introduction of a new member
Re: Introduction of a new member
As it always happens, I've sort of fallen for a lovey (pricey) instrument. It's used, a few years old. Couple of dings. But it's beautiful.
May I ask, thoughts on Italian spruce for the top?
Re: Introduction of a new member
The 2016 Collings? Man, you don't play around.
Varnish finish, mmmmm...
What's your daughter getting?
Enjoy.
3 Attachment(s)
Re: Introduction of a new member
Well, to start with, a late 1970s Suzuki --
https://imagizer.imageshack.com/v2/1...924/FPAQPM.jpg
https://imagizer.imageshack.com/v2/1...923/HZdAKL.jpg
https://imagizer.imageshack.com/v2/1...923/AvgdDn.jpg
And we'll see from there. I think she'll gravitate to an A type, but I image that spherical back will be less desirable compared to a more modern type.