Originally Posted by
August Watters
I played two of the Eastman bowlback mandolins, and found them to be good quality. The question, though, is whether the world needs another orchestral-level, Italian-style mandolin, well over the $1k mark. I'd much rather be dealing with an Italian luthier in that price range. At some point, some American luthier is going to realize that some of those old Brazilian rosewood bowls can be made into new, good-quality mandolins, and go to Italy to learn how to do it. For now, the power of the Pac-Rim marketers would have you think that the only option is A or F, and the only scale length is the one used by Gibson, never mind all the others in use in other traditions around the world.