luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
morning all,
Apologies if this is the wrong forum in which to ask this, but: does anyone here happen to know of a good mando-savvy luthier in or around Berlin, Germany?
I've been playing mandolin for only about a year, after violin as a youngster and many years of guitar, and am thoroughly enjoying it, but keep running into (presumably) setup-related problems (buzz, intonation, detuning, strings catching at the nut), which is just frustrating. I've been back to the shop where I bought the instrument (an Eastman MD305) several times (pre-lockdown), and the luthier there has performed various tweaks free of charge, but I get the feeling they're progressively less enthused every time I show up, so I'd appreciate any ideas you might have.
Thanks!
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
I don't know if this is any help. It's not about Berlin, but it might be a start in finding something.
https://www.mandolincafe.com/forum/a...p/t-49491.html
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Here is Mandolin Cafe's list of mandolin buiders in Germany. Might get you started. I don't see many in Berlin, admittedly, but probably worth a look. Kreuchwig in Berlin seems to do repairs, but looks more a guitar place.
https://www.mandolincafe.com/cgi-bin...search=Germany
And I found this article which certainly looks interesting
https://www.mandoisland.de/eng_mandolinenbauer.html
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Thanks for the pointers -- looks like I have some more research to do ... but at least some good places to start!
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Quote:
Originally Posted by
moocow
Thanks for the pointers -- looks like I have some more research to do ... but at least some good places to start!
I grew up in Berlin and I can highly recommend Berlin Guitars and their dedicated small team of skilled technicians https://berlin-guitars.de/werkstatt/ Also, please say hello to Leonard
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
There are a couple of points that I'd like to adress.
You bought the instrument pre lockdown from a music shop (?), luthier (?). Finding out if they are able to deal with setup issues is mandatory. I have a sad story to tell when it comes to guitar setup. I needed something done (intonation issues etc.) and went to a local guitar builder. Long story short: He made a new bridge insert that lowered the bridge so much that I got mostly buzzing. I then took the time have my guitar taken care of by Jürgen Richter (HH) and he practically did the opposite with great results.
In your neck of the woods there is the cafe member bluesmandolinman. He might know about a reliable local luthier. His last activity was in Jan.2021.
You need a luthier that knows about fretted instruments. I once had a violin builder do a bridge placement on my wonderful Strad-O-Lin. It was a disaster. The octaves were good, the rest was crap. This is due to the fact that fret placement was off by a little bit. A luthier with experience in fretted instruments would have done different tweaks.
Unfortunately some luthiers look down on your rather inexpensive instrument and if at all perform their job half heartedly. With this caveat I have found these stringed instrument builders/repair people in your neck of the woods:
- Johannes Reyels: http://www.gitarrenreparatur.info/kontakt.html
- Susanna Schulz: http://www.schulz-gitarren.de/wordpress/
- Watteau: http://www.wateauguitars.com/de/
- Tobias Traub: https://www.oroboruscustoms.com/
Mind you: These are guitar builders that may also repair/setup a mandolin. For a good luthier a mandolin setup shouldn´t be a problem.
Before you go to a luthier (again), how about trying your hand at some of the problems?
There is Rob Meldrum (a member here) sending you a free e-book about mandolin setup: http://jazzmando.com/tips/archives/002490.shtml
Brad Laird (also a member here) has some very useful tips on setup on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcy...XmKia8zm8gZkBA
In the end it´s indeed a matter of finding the (mandolin) luthier/repairperson of your choice. While living in Northern Germany (and later) I had repairs/adjustments made by Jürgen Richter, Karolinenstraße, Hamburg (part of the Schalloch team). Indeed, Rüdiger Helbig (Folk Laden Munich) should be able to point you in the direction of a trustworthy repair person. There are other people also, some of which fly under the radar but this should be a start.
Please report about your findings. This site is a source for others to find help/answers to question like yours.
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Lot's of good info above!
You can also sent an email to Martin Hense from
https://www.martinsmusikkiste.eu/impressum or Oliver Waitz from https://www.newacousticgallery.com, they probably can point you in the right direction.
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
I forgot that there is Bluegrass Breakdown, a bluegrass band in Berlin. Who if not they know of reliable luthiers in your area. They are one of the oldest bluegrass bands in Germany.
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Quote:
Originally Posted by
8strings
I grew up in Berlin and I can highly recommend Berlin Guitars
Yay, a first-hand recommendation! Thanks!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
grassrootphilosopher
You bought the instrument pre lockdown from a music shop (?), luthier (?).
sorry if I was unclear: I bought from a local(-ish) music shop with a good reputation, which employs a luthier on staff. Names have been omitted to protect the innocent (they really have been quite helpful, I may just be picky and/or have too high expectations).
Quote:
Originally Posted by
grassrootphilosopher
Before you go to a luthier (again), how about trying your hand at some of the problems?
In fact, I wrote to Rob shortly after starting this thread and received his e-book today (thanks, Rob!). I'll try my hand at setting up the €60 house-brand instrument I started with before I trust myself to mess around with the nut on the Eastman. Compared to many instruments played by forum members, I'm sure even the Eastman qualifies as an inexpensive, entry-level instrument, but it's the best I can afford for the foreseeable future, and I don't want to make things even worse (it's still a lot more fun to play than the no-name "Rogue"-like model). That said, I have nudged the bridge around a bit and given the wheels a few turns (without tension!) to get tolerable intonation and ameliorate some of the buzz, but I don't trust myself to mess too much with the nut.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
grassrootphilosopher
Please report about your findings. This site is a source for others to find help/answers to question like yours.
Indeed, I will keep you all posted (pun very much intendend). Thank you all for the many helpful suggestions!
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Hope you are getting on ok. Being from northern Germany as well, I am curious who you ended up contacting for further services, if you decided to go that route.
Cheers, J.
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Evening all,
I finally managed to overcome my inertia and wound up bringing the beast to Johannes ("Henry") Reyels ( http://www.gitarrenreparatur.info/ ), chosen more or less based on the fact that his was the least bleeding-edge-whizbang-klickibunti (= most "punk") website of the Berlin luthiers I looked at (also the only one to explicitly mention mandolins). He was very friendly, not at all disparaging of the "budget" instrument, and after having had it back for over a week now, I'm very happy with his work. Neither buzz nor de-tuning problems have re-occurred (they would have by now with the previous setup), intonation and projection are both improved (presumably the bridge was a bit wonky, too). Thanks to all for your input!
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
just for completion, there is a mandolin maker near Frankfurt too, she offers new construction of classical guitars and mandolins and the repair of plucked instruments. Heidi Ritter, info@diemusikwerkstatt.de, http://www.diemusikwerkstatt.de
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Quote:
Originally Posted by
moocow
Evening all,
I finally managed to overcome my inertia and wound up bringing the beast to Johannes ("Henry") Reyels (
http://www.gitarrenreparatur.info/ ), chosen more or less based on the fact that his was the least bleeding-edge-whizbang-klickibunti (= most "punk") website of the Berlin luthiers I looked at (also the only one to explicitly mention mandolins). He was very friendly, not at all disparaging of the "budget" instrument, and after having had it back for over a week now, I'm very happy with his work. Neither buzz nor de-tuning problems have re-occurred (they would have by now with the previous setup), intonation and projection are both improved (presumably the bridge was a bit wonky, too). Thanks to all for your input!
Nice followup.
We know now, that there was an issue with the bridge.
If you could resume what Johannes Reyels did for your mandolin a future search for mandolin repair people will reveal what you may expect.
I know it sometimes is difficult (for the player) to sum up what the luthier did. If you know, give us some info.
Re: luthier recommendations in or around Berlin, Germany
Quote:
Originally Posted by
grassrootphilosopher
I know it sometimes is difficult (for the player) to sum up what the luthier did. If you know, give us some info.
Apologies for not seeing this sooner. For the record (in case this thread turns up in someone else's search):
- de-tuning problems were due to sub-optimal nut-slots (strings catching at the nut)
- buzz was due to a too-deeply cut nut slot for the problem string (outer A, also the one with the worst de-tuning problems)
- the luthier's solution was to remove the nut, shim it up with a sliver of ebony (= fingerboard material), and deepen all the nut-slots by the height of the shim (slightly less in the case of the buzzing string), with slot-widths appropriate for the string gauges I've been using
- the problems at the bridge (= minor intonation issues over all strings) were minimal (to my ears), but still noticeably improved by the luthier's setup work (bridge repositioning)