Week #434 ~ The Battle of the Somme

  1. Barbara Shultz
    Barbara Shultz
    This week's winner is The Battle of the Somme, which was submitted as a Scottish tune by J. S. Skinner. I'm not sure about the J. S. Skinner part! One place I found this: Written as a retreat march by Pipe-Major William Lawrie, 1881-1916.

    I found it on thesession.org.

    Here it is from John Chambers collection on abcnotation

    And another from abcnotation

    Looks to me the hardest part, is going to be remembering just how the timing goes, with those dotted eighth notes in different places!







  2. Jill McAuley
    Jill McAuley
    Oh, I think I'll have to have a go of this one on the mandola once I get the new bridge on it and new strings this weekend!
  3. John Kelly
    John Kelly
    Great to see this one coming up, Barbara. I'll post a new version on mandolin only as soon as I can. The tune is indeed by PM Willie Lawrie rather than Scott Skinner.

    In the meantime here is a link to a version I did a few years back, on octave and tenor guitar. First tune is PM John McLellan's "Bloody Fields of Flanders".
  4. David Hansen
    David Hansen
    Very nice, John, your octave sound great. Here's a link to this tune as an "other" from 2010:

    https://www.mandolincafe.com/forum/g...330&do=discuss

    My original post is mysteriously absent, I will go and try to find it.
  5. maudlin mandolin
    maudlin mandolin


    Here it is in the key of C.
  6. David Hansen
    David Hansen
    Nicely done Maudlin. I found my original post but I didn't like the backup so I re-recorded it with new backing on cittern, bass & organ.

  7. John Kelly
    John Kelly
    Well done, gents. Two different interpretations you have put your own stamp on.
    As promised, here is my updated offering, on mandolin with guitar backing.

  8. Barbara Shultz
    Barbara Shultz
    I love all your versions, and I love the way it sounds played 'straight'... however, since this is a Scottish tune, and the version I found (notation) has it with all kinds of syncopation, and I remember my music teacher friend, telling me about Scottish Snaps... I decided to record this that way! I have no idea if this is how anyone else plays it... but here goes!

  9. John Kelly
    John Kelly
    Your interpretation of our Scottish snap is admirable, Barbara. I try to achieve it by hammer-ons and pull-offs, easier to play on Octave with its longer scale. You might hear it in the first video I posted above of the pipe march set. Fiddlers always talk of the snap and it is the element which gives the Strathspey its very distinctive style. The Strathspey only exists in Scottish music, as far as I am aware, and in the world of bagpiping the pipers talk of the dot and cut (dotted quaver followed by semi-quaver) , or cut and dot, which is the first one reversed. It is common in lots of our pipe tunes such as 2/4 and 6/8 marches, etc.
  10. Bertram Henze
    Bertram Henze
    David, John and Maudlin... everybody is here, and now our guardian angel is playing a Scottish tune.
    P. P. Rubens foresaw this when he painted heaven.
  11. Jill McAuley
    Jill McAuley
    Absolutely lovely version Barbara!
  12. gortnamona
    gortnamona
    setting the bar high with this one folks, some beautiful versions there, well done all
  13. Kay Kirkpatrick
    Kay Kirkpatrick
    This is a great tune, fairly easy on the fingering and not too fast. It's a fine example of why I have lurked around for years. Thanks to all for their submissions so far. It is truly enjoyable to hear it played in different ways.
  14. luurtie
    luurtie
    This is indeed a great tune. I listened to all the versions and I wonder if there are more of these kind Scottisch tunes. It keeps me practising. John, you give the tune the drive that make's me wanna dance (a bit strange, I never dance). David, you made a wonderful production as always. Have you ever made a weblog, or thought about making one with all of your tunes like I did last week? I never knew making one was so easy and you have made so much beautiful productions, there must be some archive anywhere. Barbara an Maudlin, you both did good work on the tune, and I agree with John about the Scottisch Snap in you playing Barbara. That's how it has to be played!
  15. Kay Kirkpatrick
    Kay Kirkpatrick
    I began with the first, 'straight' version from The Session. The more I listened to Barbara's version with the Scottish Snaps (thanks for naming them.. I learned something) I began working on one of those very syncopated versions. It certainly adds a lot to the fun of the tune.
Results 1 to 15 of 15