PDA

View Full Version : Off-line auctions



Martin Jonas
May-17-2004, 8:29am
In these days of eBay it's easy to forget that there are still traditional antiques auctions about and that some of them involve mandolins. I can't recall whether it was mentioned here at the time, but I've just stumbled across the web pages of an auction that took place in Bristol in June 2003, where a large collection of musical instruments were sold (the Mickleburgh collection). The catalogue pages with some nice photos are still on line. The list of all lots with valuations is here (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/others/SalePrices_1.html) and a few items stick out:

de Meglio (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/105.html) valued at £40 to £60, sold at £105.

de Santis (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/54.html) valued at £70 to £100, sold at £520.

Ruocco (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/64.html) valued at £50 to £70, sold at £140 (this one looks virtually identical to the de Meglio above).

Another de Meglio (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/70.html) valued at £70 to £100, sold at £370.

Two mandolins and one lute (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/88.html) sold as a single lot, valued at £70 to £100, sold at £115. I have some difficulty visualising this combination of instruments being so cheap in a specialised instuments auction. Seeing that the "lute" is described as "eight string", I'm not too sure it is actually a lute anyway.

Stridente (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/89.html) sold at £105.

Two mandolins and a guitar (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/98.html) sold at £100. These look a bit rough, admittedly.

A mandobass (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/59.html), valued at £70 to £100, sold at £270 and another (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/58.html), sold at £260.

Some auction!

The same site also has listings of other past auction, but unfortunately without photographs. I see, however, that they sold a 1880 Vinaccia with original case in 2001 for £160 (no idea of the condition, obviously).

Martin

Jim Garber
May-17-2004, 9:15am
Two mandolins and one lute (http://www.bristolauctionrooms.com/mickleburgh/lots/88.html) sold as a single lot, valued at £70 to £100, sold at £115. #I have some difficulty visualising this combination of instruments being so cheap in a specialised instuments auction. #Seeing that the "lute" is described as "eight string", I'm not too sure it is actually a lute anyway.
Interesting concept, Martin. You say these folks actually have instruments in front of you and auction them off without a computer hookup? #How strange! #http://www.mandolincafe.net/iB_html/non-cgi/emoticons/smile.gif

Thanks for bringing that to our attention. It seems like deja vous tho. I swear many of these end up on ebay anyway.

For instance, I have seen the abovementioned "lute". There have been a few on ebay over the last year or so. One was labelled 'Viennese College of Music" but I believe they were made in the UK.

Jim

Eugene
May-17-2004, 11:29am
I wish we had auctions like that here! The "Two mandolins and one lute" look to be what I would call one weird English mandolinetto thingy, one mandolin, and one mandola/mandoliola.

Jim Garber
May-17-2004, 11:45am
The weird English mandolinetto thingy... here is another one sold on eBay last year.

vkioulaphides
May-17-2004, 12:44pm
It is, of course, a bit silly to even seek rhyme or reason behind that magical point where market forces find some equilibrium but still, it is curious that the lower-end de Meglio (1A, like mine) sold for GBP370, while the higher-end one (listed first) for only GBP104. But, as the auction was live, with hands-on inspection possible (unlike eBay), the savvy buyer may have found serious issues with the fancier instrument.

Alex Timmerman
May-17-2004, 3:07pm
Hello MartinJonas,


Very nice, these are really the auctions to watch for!

If I had known that there was this Giovanni De Santis to bid on, I would have tried my luck...

It is, judging to it´s size, likely a mandola and in my eyes absolutely beautiful. And that for only £520,- ........


Anyway, thanks for the pictures, it is nice to know that instruments like this one are still to be found!


Regards,

Alex