Anyone got suggestions
Anyone got suggestions
I personally prefer a mandolin that has nearly no sustain. It tends to muddy the tone. I like the notes to snap off the string and be fat and round sounding and then disappear quickly. That seems to allow great clarity and note separation. Hope this helps.
It doesn't matter . . . I'm going to WINFIELD!!!!!
To me this is one of the things that really separates the oval-hole from the F-hole sound. Like Goose, I also like a big, fat note that drops right off, and if you want a note to be there longer for any reason (on an F-hole) that can be (seem to be) done by leaving the space in the timing or by tremolo. Oval-holes seem to ring on forever, particularly on the trebles, and that is great if that is what you want. Norman Blake talked about how you have to constantly "woo" a good F-hole mandolin to give up it's tone, whereas the sound "just falls out" of a good oval-hole. He has a wide collection of vintage Gibson oval-holes that he almost invariably plays and his wife's Loar (that used to be his!) to choose from, so I think he is OK though. Nancy described an F-hole to be indespensible for someone who was a "rhythm hound" like their friend Sam Bush.
But Amsterdam was always good for grieving
And London never fails to leave me blue
Paris never was my kinda town
So I walked around with the Ft. Worth Blues
Since this is the electrics forum, I'm going to say round hole v f-hole isnt going to make a lot of difference, especially considering the main issue in having hollow body electrics is gain before feedback, regardless of aperture shape.
I don't have a dedicated sustain pedal, but my EH memoryman (stereo w/ hazarai) keeps me happy.
Very versatile pedal, certainly not a one trick pony.
I can dial in a sustain using delay with plenty of decay, and the filter to roll of the high freqs , leaving the low end to boom on without the attack being audibly repeated.
Hereby & forthwith, any instrument with an odd number of strings shall be considered broken. With regard to mix levels, usually the best approach is treating the mandolin the same as a cowbell.
I don't mess with pedals, but from a builders perspective, I find my maple instruments to have more sustain than the koa/mahogany instruments. Both are what I consider to be semihollow bodies. I also don't extend the center support block through to the neck, thus not bridging the gap between the bridge and the neck, which I think lessens the sustain compared to a solid body or through neck design. I find that my blues and jazz customers want a bit of sustain but not the "wolf tone" effect. I'm sure Pete Mallison can weigh in on this because he's a rocker and I'd bet that's what he's looking for.
I have a suggestion - be specific. Take a little time and tell people what you want to know. This is much too vague, and invites responses that are all over the place. Or snarky. We are here to help, but need to know what to help you with.
I personally like a mandolin with sustain but, there again, I'm not a bluegrass player. A good round/oval hole flattop/induced arch should not have a muddy tone or lack clarity and definition.
Gary Nava 2-point
Di Mauro Model 10 "Muguet"
Fairbanks-Vega 1922 Whyte Laydie short-scale tenor banjo
Dobro round-neck guitar
A mind is like a parachute. It doesn't work if it is not open.
Switch to violin or dobro?
2012 Ford Escape
Fender Medium Guitar Pick
3 Cats & 1 Worn-Out Dog
Assuming that this is about electric mandolins, Dyna Comp Compressor (nfi)
I suppose, if you equate it to the early days of electric guitars, heavyweights like Les Pauls and Telecasters were pretty dense hunks of wood so there was less damping but then again, amplifiers were a bit pathetic......then there`s the consideration of what is a "fashionable" tone and then there`s the evolution of playing styles..........Massive subject!!!!!!
My guess would be that for a longer sustaining note in a quiet environment, then a dense slab of maple will rule.......but tonally, in a rocky situation, I`d go with a light instrument - something that`s going to be excited by the sound from the backline or more probably the foldback into singing.......almost like an acoustic on the verge of feedback.......more tonal character.
With this in mind, I`m just putting the finishing touches to a 5 string with an Idigbo body (an African wood around 3/5 the density of mahogany). I bought a plank of this just to try as a fun experiment and it`s so resonant....rang like a bell when I tapped it ....obviously, I`ll report the results
Play into a Looper , the electronics will do the sustaining then..
Instruments with longer strings would have longer sustain.. But mandolins have shorter strings.
writing about music
is like dancing,
im playing a five string electric j bovier emc and am just starting to get into the pedal market, i'm generally playing in pretty jam bandy situations (covering alot of phish, dead, and jamgrass stuff) and when it comes to electric jamming sustain is essential, so im thinking of just getting a ts9 tube screamer with a compressor but those are all pretty guitary effects and im not sure how they'll work with my 5 string so im just looking for something that'll work better with a mando.
Sometimes I want all the sustain I can get, typically when I'm playing my mandolin more like a little electric guitar than a mandolin. When I'm playing more mandolin style msic, with tremolo, etc., I tend to want to sound to drop off. Sustain is one tool, but an electric mando is a Swiss Army Knife.