J. Bovier A5 vs. Eastman MD 615

[Karen Mccarthy]

I have the fortunate problem of needing to choose between these 2 mandolins. I haven't played either. Both are being sold at the same price $600.00. The J. Bovier has a CA bridge upgrade. I know I need to play them both but the timing of that is going to be tricky so I'm trying to get as much input beforehand to help me in the decision. Any experience with either instrument will be helpful.

Thanks

[Folkmusician.com]

I would go with the Eastman 615 unless there was some sort of issue with it. It is a more valuable mandolin (by almost double I believe) and in this case also the better instrument.

[ourgang]

You've got to play the Bovier before you buy. I've seen them all over the place in tone and volume. Just not too consistant. Can't speak to the Eastman, I've only seen one F-style, but it was pretty good.

[jake-mando]

I agree that you need to play both. I have a J. Bovier and Iam very happy with it. I don't know about being worth double. My Dorado lists at $1700.00 Which seems to be around the same list price for the Eastman. The one thing I like is that if I have a question about the mando I can shoot a quick "hey hows it going" to Jeff Cowherd. Jeff is the guy that designs and has these mando's made. It comes down to playability and sound. If you like it buy it.

[Folkmusician.com]

Hi Jake,

I believe your Dorado is one of the highest models. Your mandolin lists for more than the Eastman.

The J. Bovier A5 lists for $779. Not that it is a bad mandolin, but the Eastman at $600 would be the better value in my opinion.