View Full Version : Gibson F-5 model differences
I'm considering having Gibson build me a custom mando, and was wondering about the tonal differnces between the various signature models. I already own a Bush, which I'd describe as rich, mellow, and somewhat darker toned compared to other F's out there. How do the Steffy, Benson, and Master models line up in the continuum. What sorts of design goals are behind each model ? I'd love to hear from Big Joe or Charlie, as well as owners who've done their own research before purchasing. Thanks in advance!
BigJoe
Apr-17-2004, 4:01pm
The Artist models are pretty similar except for some of the trip/color on the instruments. The exceptions are the Bush (larger neck) and the Lawson which has bound F holes which alter the tone a little. Gives it somewhat of an X braced tone. Very nice. Then the Master Model is in a class of its own. The woods, glue, and finish are different which give it the 'loar' sound. They are so close that it is hard to tell which is which if your eyes are closed. The other artist models have more of a F5 Fern sound. Very nice and warm with a real sweetness to it. I realize describing tone is like describing the taste of a pizza to someone. Very hard. If you have an opportunity, come to the Gibson Bluegrass Showcase where all of them are usually available to try. You can make up your own mind then. Thank you for asking and I wish I could be more helpful.
Joe Parker
Apr-17-2004, 7:34pm
Big Joe-When did Sam Bush adopt the unique string spacing at the nut that was a feature on the Bush models? I was watching an instructional video he did in 1984 and at that time he was still using standard spacing. Just curious.
Joe Parker
Bob Sayers
Apr-18-2004, 10:45am
I had the opportunity last month to play all of the different Artist models (except the Bibey model) at Mandolin Bros. #It was difficult--and perhaps a little unfair--to compare them tone-wise, except that I thought that the Sam Bush model on display had the most mature bluegrassy sound. #
Having said this, the one that most attracted my attention was--somewhat surprisingly--the Wayne Benson model. #I just fell in love with the dark red wine color (very close to a vintage F-4), satin finish, and blue abalone fern. #Up close, it's much richer looking than in the web pictures and a happy alternative to brown mandolin! #
The end of the story is that I wound up buying it last week and couldn't be happier. I would describe the tone as round and mellow, but with sufficient punch for bluegrass. #
Bob